Mammography Has Low Risk of Recall for False Positive Findings
Behind the Cancer Headlines®
August 25, 2004
A new long-term study finds that only one in five women who have mammograms every two years will have to undergo follow up evaluation for a false positive finding. Only one in 16 will have an unnecessary invasive procedure over two decades. The 20-year study, published in the journal Cancer, should reassure physicians and patients that the risks of breast cancer screening are minimal given the notable benefit of breast cancer screening.
Breast cancer screening by regular screening mammography has a proven benefit to saving lives. However, false positives and subsequent recall for follow-up evaluation can create significant psychosocial distress.
The extent of false positive recall is unclear. Previous studies have claimed the cumulative risk of a high false positive recall over the years was significant. However, the estimates and conclusions made to date are weakened by flawed study designs.
Solveig Hofvind, M.Sc., and her colleagues from the Cancer Registry of Norway reviewed data of 83,416 women from the Norwegian Breast Cancer Screening program, a uniform national program providing biennial screening mammography for women 50 to 69 years of age.
The authors found that women who began biennial screening mammography at age 50 or 51 and participated in screening for 20 years had a cumulative 20-year risk for false positive recall of 20.8 percent. The risk for undergoing invasive procedures with benign findings was considerably lower at 6.2 percent. Most of those were for fine needle aspiration (3.9 percent). Only about one in 66 women had a core biopsy with benign findings (1.5 percent). Even fewer had open biopsy with benign findings (0.9 percent).
Given this low 20-year risk level, conclude the authors, "all the estimates seem to be quite acceptable and ought to be communicated to the target group."
Cancer, online edition, August 23, 2004